Crow standing on a green cabbageCrow & CabbageFound & ForagedMy wins 0
← Garden

Growing shallots

I plant my shallots in the fall here in Utah, and they've done wonderfully! I couldn't tell you exactly which variety I'm growing, but whatever they are, they're clearly happy with the arrangement. After planting, I cover the bed with about an inch of fallen leaves shredded with the lawn mower. The mulch helps protect the soil through winter, and when spring comes I check that the new shoots aren't buried under matted leaves. Fall planting has worked for me, but variety, drainage and winter conditions matter; spring planting may suit other gardens better.

Planting timing (fall vs spring sets)

Planting timing (Salt Lake East Bench)

Outside Utah, check your local extension for dates.

  • Plant shallot sets (or seed) in early spring, as soon as the ground can be worked. USU treats sets as the usual method. [1]
  • Utah planting guides give different spring windows for onions and do not give a separate shallot calendar. Use workable soil, your local frost pattern and variety-specific advice rather than a fixed citywide date. [2] [3]
  • Fall option: plant sets after the first frost, for a late-spring harvest. Very cold winters can reduce yield. In zones 4 or 5, protect fall plantings with frost cloth or mulch. [1]
  • USU does not give a calendar date for that first frost. A USU table lists Salt Lake City’s average first fall freeze as 16 October, and the average last spring freeze as 26 April [4]. Wasatch Front last-spring dates vary by site (Airport 26 April; University of Utah 1 May) [2]. There is no confirmed an East Bench-specific frost date or hardiness zone, so use a local frost date, not the city averages alone.

Spacing, soil, and water

  • Full sun and fertile, well-drained soil, rich in organic matter. Preferred pH is 5.5–7.5. If a soil test calls for fertilizer, work it into the top 15 cm (6 in). If you use compost, apply no more than 2.5 cm (1 in) of well-composted organic matter per 9.3 m² (100 sq ft). [1]
  • Plant sets 2.5–5 cm (1–2 in) deep and 8–15 cm (3–6 in) apart, in rows 30–46 cm (12–18 in) apart. Close spacing gives smaller, single bulbs; wider spacing can make clusters (USU: 10–15 bulbs). Keep spacing close if you want green onions. [1]
  • Water regularly and keep the soil near field capacity. Wet the soil thoroughly 20–30 cm (8–12 in) deep; use drip irrigation if possible. Drought stress reduces growth, yield, and weight. Overwatering contributes to bulb rot. [1]
  • If a soil test and crop growth indicate a need for nitrogen, USU’s reference rate is 225g (½ lb) of 21-0-0 per 9.3m² (100 sq ft), at 30 and 60 days after planting. Adapt fertilizer to soil fertility and your season; do not apply automatically. Avoid late nitrogen as bulbs mature. [1]
  • Sources disagree on set spacing: Clemson (non-USU, written for South Carolina) uses 15–20 cm (6–8 in). [9] USU does not say to plant the tip up, or to leave developing bulbs uncovered. Virginia and Clemson (both non-USU) do: pointed tip up, tip just at the soil line, and do not cover bulbs that form on the surface. [9] [10]

Harvest signs

  • For green shallots: harvest when tops are 15–20 cm (6–8 in) tall, or about 50–60 days after planting. This also thins the row. [1]
  • For dry bulbs: harvest after the tops fall over. The fact-sheet intro says “when most of the tops have fallen over.” Maturity date varies by variety. Lift the bulbs and gently separate clusters into individual bulbs. [1]
  • Sources disagree on how far the tops should go. Clemson (non-USU) waits until the tops have died down completely. Virginia (non-USU) harvests when the tops have turned yellow. [9] [10]
  • USU does not give a harvest month for Utah shallots. Do not use Virginia’s “mid- to late summer” as a Utah date. [10]
  • USU says to harvest shallots similarly to onions. For onions, USU says stop watering when the tops fall over; extra water delays curing and causes storage problems. [1] [5] The shallot fact sheet itself does not say to stop watering.

Curing

Curing (steps, time, and conditions)

  • USU’s shallot sheet: after lifting, leave the bulbs in the garden to cure for 1–2 weeks, until the bulbs and leaves are completely dry and the skin is papery. Then braid the tops, or cut the leaves 5 cm (2 in) above the bulb, before storing. [1]
  • USU does not describe indoor rack curing for shallots, and it gives no indoor temperature. The closest USU home-garden language is for onions and garlic, not shallots: a well-ventilated area out of the sun (onions: out of direct sunlight) for 2–3 weeks, until the outer skin “rustle[s] when disturbed” and the necks are dry [6]. USU’s onion and garlic garden sheets instead say 1–2 weeks in the garden (onions, with the tops shading the bulbs) or in a shady, warm spot (garlic), until the skin is papery and the roots are dry. [5] [7]
  • Sources disagree on place and time: in the garden vs a shaded, airy place; 1–2 weeks vs 2–3 weeks. The 2–3 week, out-of-the-sun figures are written for onions and garlic, not shallots.
  • Non-USU shallot guidance: Clemson and Virginia say cure in a warm, dry place for about a week. [9] [10] Clemson describes garlic — not shallots — spread in a single layer on screens or drying racks, in a warm, shady place with good air movement, for about 2–3 weeks, until the neck is dry and the outer skin is papery. [9]
  • USU’s commercial onion guide (not a home-garden sheet) warns: do not cut through a top that is still green or moist, or neck rot can follow in storage. [8]

Storage

  • Store in mesh bags in a cool, dry place at 0–4°C (32–40°F). [1]
  • USU’s storage table puts shallots with onions and garlic: cold and dry, 0–4°C (32–40°F), and 60–70% humidity. A cold, dry basement room is best; store in the dark in slatted crates or mesh bags. [6]
  • Properly stored shallot bulbs can be replanted in spring. [1]
  • USU does not say how long shallots keep. Virginia (non-USU) gives six months or longer at those same temperatures and 60–70% humidity. Both Virginia and Clemson say to use or replant smaller bulbs first, because they do not keep well. [9] [10]
  • For onions, USU says to check regularly and use any that are softening or sprouting first. [5] That is not stated for shallots.

Common mistakes

Common mistakes (only those the sources state)

  • Overwatering contributes to bulb rot. Drought during growth reduces growth, yield, and weight. [1]
  • Fertilizing after mid-July causes late leaf growth, can reduce bulb size, lowers storage potential, and can contribute to bulb rots. [1]
  • Fall plantings can lose yield in very cold winters if they are not protected. USU specifies frost cloth or mulch in zones 4 or 5. [1]
  • Rough, deep cultivation can damage roots and slow growth. Weeds matter most in the first two months. Avoid watering at night or wetting the plants (Botrytis), and do not crowd plants (downy mildew needs airflow). [1]
  • Non-USU (Virginia): bulb rot from bruising or planting too deeply. [10]
  • Related onion guidance, not stated for shallots: extra water as the tops fall over delays curing and causes storage problems [5]; cutting through a still-green or moist top can lead to neck rot in storage [8].

Sources

1. Utah State University Extension. How to Grow Shallots in Your Garden. Emmalee Rolfe and Dan Drost. Peer-reviewed fact sheet, published September 2022. https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/shallots-in-the-garden

2. Utah State University Extension. Suggested Vegetable Planting Dates For the Wasatch Front. Shawn Olsen. Peer-reviewed fact sheet, published January 2018. https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/wasatch-front-planting-dates

3. Utah State University Extension. The Pocket Gardener: A Quick Guide to Home Vegetable Gardening. Sheriden Hansen, JayDee Gunnell, and Dan Drost. https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/files/usu-pocket-gardener.pdf

4. Utah State University Extension. Annuals for Utah Gardens, Table 1, “Average last spring and first fall freeze days.” Salt Lake City: average last spring freeze 26 April; average first fall freeze 16 October; 172 freeze-free days. https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/annuals-for-utah-gardens

5. Utah State University Extension. How to Grow Onions in Your Garden. Dan Drost. Peer-reviewed fact sheet, published May 2020. https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/onions-in-the-garden

6. Utah State University Extension. Harvest and Storage of Vegetables and Fruits. Shawn Olsen, Dan Drost, and Teresa Hunsaker. Peer-reviewed fact sheet, published January 2015. https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/harvest-and-storage-of-vegetables-and-fruits

7. Utah State University Extension. How to Grow Garlic in Your Garden. Dan Drost. Peer-reviewed fact sheet, published May 2020. https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/garlic-in-the-garden

8. Utah State University Extension. Onion: Harvest and Handling (Utah Vegetable Production and Pest Management Guide; commercial production, not a home-garden sheet). https://extension.usu.edu/vegetableguide/onion/harvest-handling

9. Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home & Garden Information Center. Onion, Leek, Shallot, & Garlic. HGIC 1314. Updated 20 January 2023. Non-USU; written for South Carolina. https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/onion-leek-shallot-garlic/

10. Virginia Cooperative Extension. Onions, Garlic, and Shallots. Publication 426-411 (SPES-788P). Diane Relf, Alan McDaniel; reviewed by Edward Olsen. Non-USU. https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/content/dam/pubs_ext_vt_edu/426/426-411/SPES-788.pdf

USU’s shallot fact sheet also cites Leonard Perry, University of Vermont, Shallots and scallions, and an older URL for the Virginia sheet (SPES-254).